Cooking With Red Bell Peppers: How to Choose, Roast, Grill, and Use Them

Red bell peppers are sweet peppers, not hot chile peppers. They have thick, crisp walls, plenty of moisture and a naturally sweet flavor that becomes even richer when they are roasted, grilled or sautéed. That makes them useful raw as well as cooked.

Although bell peppers belong to the same broad pepper family as many hot chiles, bell peppers do not have the noticeable capsaicin heat associated with jalapeños, serranos and other hot peppers. This guide focuses specifically on the sweet red bell pepper and the cooking methods that bring out its best flavor.

What Makes a Red Bell Pepper Different?

Red bell peppers are mature sweet peppers. Many bell pepper cultivars begin green and develop their mature color as they ripen, but they do not all pass through a fixed green-to-yellow-to-orange-to-red sequence. The final color depends on the variety. As a bell pepper matures, its green chlorophyll decreases while pigments, aromas and sugars develop, which is why a ripe red bell pepper generally tastes sweeter than an immature green one.

That sweetness makes red bell peppers especially useful when you want pepper flavor without adding chile heat.

How to Choose and Store Red Bell Peppers

Choose peppers that feel firm and heavy for their size, with smooth, taut skin and a fresh-looking green stem. A few natural shape variations are harmless, but avoid peppers with large soft spots, deep wrinkles or signs of mold.

Keep whole bell peppers dry and refrigerated, preferably in the crisper drawer, and wash them just before using. Once cut, store the pieces in a covered container in the refrigerator and use them while they are still crisp.

How to Prepare a Red Bell Pepper

Wash and dry the pepper, then cut around or through the stem and remove the seeds. The pale interior ribs are edible, but trimming them away gives you cleaner pieces and a more even texture. From there, the pepper can be sliced into strips, diced, left in larger panels for grilling, or roasted whole.

Eating Red Bell Peppers Raw

Raw red bell peppers are crisp, juicy and sweet. Slice them for salads, sandwiches, wraps and vegetable platters, or dice them into salsas and grain salads. Their sweetness pairs particularly well with salty cheeses, vinaigrettes, fresh herbs and creamy dips.

Roasting and Grilling Red Bell Peppers

Roasting or grilling is one of the best ways to deepen the flavor of a red bell pepper. High heat softens the flesh, concentrates its sweetness and creates browned or charred flavors on the surface.

Roasted red bell peppers used in a savory dish

Roasted or grilled bell peppers work as a quesadilla filling, sandwich topping, salad ingredient, side dish or starting point for a sauce.

For a deeply roasted pepper, cook it until the skin is blistered and charred in spots. After roasting, covering the hot peppers briefly can help loosen the skin. Peel it away if you want a silky texture for sauces or spreads. For many rustic dishes, removing every bit of skin is unnecessary.

Try roasted red peppers in Loaded Vegetable & Meat Quesadillas With a Chipotle Dipping Sauce, a Hot Pastrami Sandwich With Provolone Cheese & Roasted Sweet Peppers, or Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Sweet Peppers & Bacon.

Stir-Frying and Sautéing

Bell peppers contain plenty of water, so they respond well to quick cooking over fairly high heat. Slice them evenly and avoid crowding the pan if you want browned edges while keeping some crispness. Cook them longer over moderate heat when you want a softer, sweeter result.

Korean beef stir-fry with red bell peppers

Try them in my Korean Beef Stir-Fry With a Homemade Asian Sauce.

Making Roasted Red Pepper Sauces

Roasted red bell peppers purée into naturally sweet, colorful sauces. After roasting, blend them with ingredients such as garlic, olive oil, herbs, Parmesan or a creamy ingredient depending on the dish. Because the peppers already contain substantial moisture, you can often build a smooth sauce without adding much extra liquid.

Lentil pasta with broccoli and roasted red pepper sauce — Lentil Pasta With Broccoli & Roasted Red Pepper Sauce

Mediterranean omelette with roasted red pepper sauce — Lentil Pasta With Broccoli & Roasted Red Pepper Sauce

What About Paprika?

Paprika is also a pepper product, but it is not simply ground fresh red bell pepper. Paprika is made from dried peppers in the Capsicum annuum species, and the varieties used and the way they are dried determine whether the finished spice tastes sweet, earthy, hot or smoky. Treat paprika as a separate pantry spice rather than as a substitute for fresh red bell pepper.

Flavor Pairings for Red Bell Peppers

Red bell peppers pair naturally with garlic, onions, tomatoes, basil, parsley, oregano, feta, goat cheese, Parmesan, mozzarella, chicken, beef, sausage, beans, lentils, eggs and rice. Acidic ingredients such as lemon juice, vinegar and tomatoes can balance their sweetness, while smoky spices emphasize the flavor of roasted peppers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are red bell peppers hot?

No. Bell peppers are sweet peppers and do not have the noticeable capsaicin heat found in hot chile peppers.

Are red bell peppers sweeter than green bell peppers?

Generally, yes. A red bell pepper has been allowed to mature further, giving it time to develop more sweetness and a different flavor than an immature green pepper.

Do I have to peel roasted red peppers?

No. Peeling is most useful when you want a particularly smooth sauce, spread or tender finished texture. For many cooked dishes, leaving some of the skin is perfectly fine.

Can red bell peppers be frozen?

Yes. Wash, seed and cut them before freezing. Frozen peppers lose some of their raw crispness after thawing, but they work well in cooked dishes such as soups, sauces, stir-fries and casseroles.

Still hungry? These recent recipes are ready when you are.